Our Family

Just before serving in the US Army for several years, my brother and I opened up Spicer Pizza Supply which was a staple in our town Newark, Ohio for over 30 years. In 1995 we began focusing on fundraisers for community schools and other groups. After my son graduated from Newark High School, he continued in fundraising as I entered the insurance industry in 2005. He joined me 2 years later and we’ve been a strong team and force to be reckoned with ever since!

With over 15 years of experience in the Medicare health insurance business I am highly qualified to educate people about their insurance options. Being able to help clients find an appropriate insurance plan for them is highly rewarding for me and I’m thankful for having that opportunity, especially during these difficult times. I am available to answer questions, discuss plan options and enroll members. 

I am proud of this business which has allowed me to work closely with several family members and friends. Our agency continues to grow with new agents being frequently added to Family Favorites, LTD and we would be pleased to invite you to join our family, too! 

Since becoming an Independent Licensed Agent in 2007 and joining my father as a partner-owner in the Family Favorites, LTD Agency, I am proud to say our focus has been to expand the Family in Family Favorites. From just the two of us starting out in Licking County, Ohio to now having over a dozen agents servicing all of Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Alabama, and Florida.
Born and raised in Newark, Ohio and now raising my own family here, I understand how overwhelming planning for the future can be. I have dedicated myself to help simplify the process of comparing your Medicare and Life Insurance or Annuity options. Contact me today to get peace of mind that you’re receiving all the benefits you’re eligible for.

Originally from Newark, Ohio and where I now reside, I’m proud to be continuing the Family Favorites, LTD name and values as your Licensed Independent Agent. Let me help educate and guide you, your family, and your friends through your choices once eligible for Medicare. I specialize in targeting your individual needs to find the right plan for you. Unsure what you’re eligible for or looking for lower costs? Contact me today for free consultation.

I am a proud Newark, Ohio native born and raised. I’m an avid animal and people lover. My clients are like extended family to me so I thoroughly enjoy going the extra mile to serve them. I’ve always worked in customer service so becoming a Licensed Independent Agent and working alongside my colleagues at Family Favorites, LTD comes natural to me. I am looking forward to helping you with your Medicare needs! Contact me for a free consultation.

I have dedicated my life to educating and helping others. I have helped people with special needs for nearly 40 years. I retired in 2011 as a Speech/Language Therapist for Newark City Schools. I enjoyed retirement as I continued to volunteer at Casey's Cupboard and in 2013 I happily joined my husband and son on the Family Favorites, LTD team! Becoming an Independent Insurance Agent has allowed me to continue helping others by finding the health care coverage that will meet your individual needs. I am licensed to present many options of Medicare plans and ACA plans for people who are not yet age 65. Contact me (and Zorro) for free consultations!

Hello, my name is Rendy Steele and I graduated from Newark High School, back when it was still a campus! I recently became an Independent Licensed Insurance Agent while still earning my Associate's Degree in Paralegal Studies at Eastern Gateway Community College. Being a goal driven and detail oriented person, I am excited and ready to help my community, especially when it comes to navigating the insurance world. Contact me for a free consultation.

I was born and raised in Alexandria, Ohio and moved to Newark, Ohio over 10 years ago after I married my wife, Ashley. Most of my career has been in the Safety and Security field which allows me to provide excellent care and customer service to people daily. I decided to become a Health Insurance agent after seeing my parents go through their Medicare process and I realized how important it is to have someone in your corner to help ensure you understand all of your Medicare options. I am excited to join the Family Favorites, Ltd team and provide you with the exceptional care and service you deserve! Contact me anytime for a free consultation.

I was born and raised in Charleston, WV. I’m a family man, married to my wife Amber and the proud dad of 3 girls! After graduating from West Virginia State University I began my insurance career as an auto claim rep for State Farm. Five years later, in 1999, I was licensed as an insurance agent and became the owner of a Nationwide auto insurance agency which specializes in auto and property insurance. I had the opportunity to join the team at Family Favorites, LTD which has allowed me to now also offer Medicare Health Insurance plans. I’m happy to be able to work with other experienced agents and this has been a wonderful addition to my list of insurance offerings. Contact me with your Medicare health, auto and property insurance needs!

Born and raised in Belgium, I moved to Ohio and eventually joined Family Favorites officially when I married Lincoln Spicer II. I enjoy working alongside my husband as the administrative and marketing side of being a licensed independent agent. I will support and guide anyone looking for answers when it comes to their health and life insurance care. Unsure which agent to speak with or have questions about us? Contact me and I’ll make sure you’re in the right hands.